German’s Respite for Coal May End as Talks Resume With Merkel

The future of Germany’s coal industry is moving back into the spotlight as Chancellor Angela Merkel restarts talks on forming a new coalition government, with pressure building for stricter limits on the most polluting fuels.

Two months after national elections, discussions aimed at forging a novel four-party government collapsed at the weekend in Berlin. While that breakdown provided a respite for shares of coal burning utilities including RWE AG and Uniper SE, the issues of carbon dioxide emissions and climate policy loom large with coalition talks set to begin again.

“Whatever emerges as the next government, at least a minimum consensus on cutting coal” should be expected, “and looks likely to stick,” said Claudia Kemfert, who heads Berlin’s DIW institute’s energy desk, on the phone Friday. Kemfert advises the government on energy policy in an independent capacity and is an exponent of a quicker coal exit.

Coal power catapulted to the center of coalition wrangling in recent weeks after signs emerged that Germany’s falling further behind in cutting emissions. That in turn prompted calls to assuage Germany’s international allies that the country is serious about meeting its commitments. A working consensus emerged among the coalition hopefuls to cut emissions, according to participants from the three of the four parties.

Coal power supplied about 40 percent of all Germany’s electricity last year but about a third of its carbon dioxide pollution. That underscores the dilemma of balancing energy security and climate protection. Germany currently has more power generation it needs to feed demand.

Essen-based Steag GmbH applied to shut six coal plants last year, leaving it with eight working units after plummeting wholesale prices made them unprofitable. Power prices have recovered this year, helping lift the sales and shares of utilities that operate them including Uniper and RWE.

Before the talks fell apart, Merkel was closing in on a deal with other parties to close about 7 gigawatt of coal power, equal to as many as 15 mid-sized plants of the roughly 130 operating in Germany, according to negotiators, who asked not to be identified because the talks were confidential. Germany has about 49 gigawatts of hard coal and lignite power capacity, a quarter of the nation’s energy mix. A gigawatt is enough to supply about 600,000 homes.

Coal power in Germany is highly concentrated and bundled mainly in the hands of five industry champions. RWE, the nation’s biggest electricity generator, has combined lignite-hard coal assets of about 26 gigawatts, an eighth of all installed power in Germany. The relatively modest generation curbs, along with the prospect for compensation may ease the plan’s acceptance by operators, according to the participants.

Capping coal power to reach the carbon dioxide target gained tentative support from the power industry’s BDEW lobby, which wrote Nov. 16 in Die Welt newspaper that a 5-gigawatt power cap was justifiable because lignite plants weren’t the sole target of closures and that those who operate the plants will have to be compensated for closing them.

Just how much the state will pay for compensation is likely to be a sticking point for the parties in coalition talks when they return to the table.

About BloombergNEF

BloombergNEF (BNEF) is a strategic research provider covering global commodity markets and the disruptive technologies driving the transition to a low-carbon economy. Our expert coverage assesses pathways for the power, transport, industry, buildings and agriculture sectors to adapt to the energy transition. We help commodity trading, corporate strategy, finance and policy professionals navigate change and generate opportunities.
Sign up for our free monthly newsletter →

Want to learn how we help our clients put it all together? Contact us