Wind and Solar’s Future Depends on Taxes, Not Clean Power Plan

Written by Joe Ryan, Brian Eckhouse and Ari Natter. This article first appeared on Bloomberg Technology. 

The Trump administration’s decision to end the Clean Power Plan may be deeply symbolic, but the battle that matters most for renewable energy will be over taxes.

Wind and solar have been the fastest growing sources of electricity in the U.S. since 2014 as utilities closed a record number of aging coal-fired generators. That’s largely because it’s become cheaper to build renewable plants than keep coal plants open.

Clean-energy’s fiscal advantage stems in part from two tax credits that Congress extended in 2015. Both measures are scheduled to be phased out in the 2020s, but Environmental Protection Agency administrator Scott Pruitt on Monday called for them to be eliminated. That could upend wind and solar’s edge.

“Without tax credits, those economics no longer work,” said Amy Grace, an analyst at Bloomberg New Energy Finance.

Unlike the Clean Power Plan, tax credits cannot be unilaterally scuttled by the White House. But with Republican Congressional leaders pushing to rewrite the tax code, opponents of the wind and solar tax credits, including those in the Trump Administration, are jockeying to torpedo the measures.

“I would do away with these incentives,” Pruitt said, responding to a question about the effectiveness of renewable energy at an event in the heart of Kentucky coal country. “I’d let them stand on their own and compete against coal and natural gas and other sources.”

Not Easy

It won’t be easy to kill the measures, know formally as the Production Tax Credit and Investment Tax Credit. They have broad support from both Democrats and Republicans from rural districts where wind and solar have become a key source of jobs. Plus, the overall prospects for reforming the tax code remain murky amidst congressional gridlock and Republican infighting.

After Pruitt called for ending the credits for wind and solar, Iowa Republican Senator Chuck Grassley said on Twitter that he would “remind” the EPA chief that the credit for wind farms “will stay on books until 2020, like Congress planned.”

Carlos Curbelo, a Republican Congressman from Florida, went further, invoking Jeopardy! game show Alex Trebek as he opined on the odds of a successful repeal of the tax credits.

“Alex, I’ll take ‘things that are not happening for $800,”’ Curbelo wrote on Twitter.

Cheap Enough

Trump’s move to kill the Clean Power Plan has not dimmed investor enthusiasm for clean energy. Since the president signed the order to roll back the emissions-curbing rule, almost $30 billion has been spent on solar and wind projects.

In the third quarter alone, clean energy spending in the U.S. hit the highest level in two years, totaling $14.8 billion, data compiled by Bloomberg New Energy Finance show.

Renewables are now cheap enough to thrive without subsidies in some parts of the world, including Brazil and Mexico. The difference is demand for electricity is growing in those regions while it has stagnated in much of the U.S.

About Bloomberg New Energy Finance

Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF) is an industry research firm focused on helping energy professionals generate opportunities. With a team of experts spread across six continents, BNEF provides independent analysis and insight, enabling decision-makers to navigate change in an evolving energy economy.
Sign up for our free weekly newsletter →

Want to learn how we help our clients put it all together? Contact us